How Romney can derail McCain (a look at state polls)

Crossposted at RedState

Here I will quickly examine latest polls and Romney's chances to actually derail the premature coronation of John McCain. Unlike the large number of people eager to get on the bandwagon, I will not jump until the fat lady has sung. Sorry. And yes, I don't know if I will ever vote for McCain as a Conservative and it will depend on his behavior if he wins the GOP nomination.

I will present the best possible scenario for Mitt Romney which I give about 10-15% chance of happening.

Current delegate totals:

McCain 95, Romney 67, Huckabee 26

Analysis of the Super Tuesday States

Alabama - Proportional Delegates [48 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 38 20 30
SurveyUSA 40 21 31
Insider Advantage 37 14 35
AEA/Capital 34 15 27

A southern state with Huckabee giving McCain some, but not enough trouble. With Romney splitting conservatives with Huckabee, McCain should pull this one out, but there is a decent chance of Huckabee catching McCain.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 20 Huckabee 18 Romney 10

Alaska - Proportional Delegates [29 total delegates]

A staunchly republican state. Bush won with over 60%. However it is a more economic conservative than a social conservative state. Survey USA Bush approval number is 43% which is definitely one of the better states for him. In FL most people who approved of Bush broke for Romney so I believe Romney at least has a fighting chance to gain some of these proportional delegates. Without serious campaign here by either candidate, McCain's national numbers should beat Romney, but Huckabee is not a factor boosting Romney.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 17 Romney 12

Arizona - Winner Takes All [53 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Behavior Res. Ctr 40 23 7
Arizona State 41 18 31

McCain's homestate should give him a comfortable margin of victory but it is also a state that knows him best. Romney could do better than expected here especially it being in the West where Romney does best (including small Mormon population). Unfortunately it is a winner takes all.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 53 Romney 0

Arkansas - Proportional Delegates [34 total delegates]

No good recent polls but last years polls show Huckabee ahead. It is Huckabee's home state and should give him a small margin of victory with McCain and Romney slightly behind.

My Optimistic Prediction: Huckabee 14 McCain 10 Romney 10

California - Proportional Delegates [173 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 32 28 11
CNN/Politico 39 26 11
Gallup 36 31 10
SurveyUSA 37 25 14

This is a big one and despite it awarding delegates proportionately it could give Romney momentum if he squeezes out a victory. Arguable there is some momentum in his favor here and his chances are better in this Western State. Many conservative republicans here angry over Illegal Immigration, an issue on which Romney dominates. He can surprise McCain here and he's focused his ad campaign here.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 83 Romney 90

Colorado - Proportional Delegates [46 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Mason Dixon 43 24 17

This is a caucus and Romney's organization should turn out the vote here. The margin might not be as big as the polls suggests but Romney will win.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 12 Romney 30 Huckabee 4

Connecticut - Winner Takes All [30 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 42 26 8
SurveyUSA 53 31 6

Romney has picked up a lot of support here since early January but it won't be enough despite CT's closeness to MA. McCain should win this moderate state comfortably.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 30 Romney 0

Delaware - Winner Takes All [18 total delegates]

No good recent polls but Giuliani ran well in this somewhat NE moderate state. The further you go down South on the Eastern Coast, the better will Romney do which is why I don't think it's certain that McCain will carry it. Thompson didn't do too
bad here in the last years polls. This could be a surprise.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 0 Romney 18

Georgia - Proportional Delegates [72 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Insider Advantage 35 24 24
Rasmussen 19 16 34

McCain made huge strides here after the FL primary. Fortunately it is proportional. It could be closer with Huckabee giving McCain a run for his money.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 28 Huckabee 28 Romney 16

Illinois - Proportional Delegates [70 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 34 26 16
Chicago Tribune 43 20 15
Research 2000 31 20 11

A midwestern but a somewhat moderate state should give McCain a victory. Hopefully Romney is running some ads here as he can pick up some support in this proportional primary. Huckabee will not be a factor in the North.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 45 Romney 25

Massachussetts - Proportional Delegates [43 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 34 55 8
SurveyUSA 34 57 3

If only it was a Winner Take All. Romney should do well here as expected but not a total blowout which he needs. Still a good margin.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 11 Romney 32

Minnesota - Proportional Delegates [41 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Minn Pub. Radio 41 17 22

This moderate midwestern state trends strongly for McCain. Despite the one poll here, I do not believe Huckabee will be a factor.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 28 Romney 13

Missouri - Winner Takes All [58 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 32 28 29
SurveyUSA 34 30 28
Research 2000 31 21 25

This state presents a chance for Romney's upset. There is some upward trending in his numbers here and with some good ad campaign he could do it. 3-way split should help him in this Winner Take All. It is my hope that on this day Conservatives will understand that only Romney has a chance against McCain and switch from Huckabee.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 0 Romney 58 Huckabee 0

Montana - Winner Takes All [25 total delegates]

No recent polls in this Western state but this is Romney country. He should be able to win this anti-establishment state.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 0 Romney 25

New Jersey - Winner Takes All [52 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 43 29 7
SurveyUSA 48 25 9
Quinnipiac 29 14 9

Despite late "surge" of support for Romney, McCain grabs most of Giuliani support here and should easily win all delegates here.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 52 Romney 0

New York - Winner Takes All [101 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
SurveyUSA 55 21 7
Gallup 40 17 11

Yeah... Well, this is a given and no surprise whatsoever. I will vote for Romney here :)

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 101 Romney 0

North Dakota - Winner Takes All [26 total delegates]

No recent polls. Bush's approval here is relatively high at 40% and It is a mid-western state which should give some chance to Romney. I'll go out on a limb and predict that this conservative state goes for Romney.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 0 Romney 26

Oklahoma - Proportional Delegates [41 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
SurveyUSA 37 19 28

Romney should at least catch up with Huckabee here as Huckabee is trending downward everywhere.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 22 Romney 10 Huckabee 9

Tennessee - Proportional Delegates [55 total delegates]

Poll McCain Romney Huckabee
Rasmussen 32 29 23
Insider Advantage 33 18 25
WSMV-TV 23 24 18

Being an insider is not always advantageous. I believe that Romney has definitely improved in this state and shows momentum. Like I said above, Huckabee is trending downward overall and Romney shows surprising strength here. All potential for an upset.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 21 Romney 23 Huckabee 11

Utah - Winner Takes All [36 total delegates]

No polls needed in this Mormon Winnter Takes All Homeland. Romney will cruise.

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 0 Romney 36

West Virginia - Winner Takes All [18 total delegates]

No recent polls here but I will boldly predict that McCain will not win here. Who knows which way it will go so I'll pull it out from my ...

My Optimistic Prediction: McCain 0 Romney 18 Huckabee 0

-----------------------------------------------------

McCain wins 9 for a total of 533 Delegates
Romney wins 11 for a total of 464 Delegates
Huckabee wins 1 for a total of 72 Delegates

If this is what happens or even if the split is 600-400, along with a potential California loss, this takes the veneer of inevitability away from McCain and extends Romney's life. Especially since this will spell the end for Huckabee. This is no time to surrender or give up on the hope of Conservative Romney winning GOP nomination and I'll wait until the fat lady sings.

Comments :

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Nice job, Ender.

I don't have much to say about the question at issue (I have no dog in this fight) but you did a damn nice job of being thorough and formatting. :)

I came. I saw. I posted.
Veni, Vidi, Bitchy.

…………

thanks man

It felt good to put my "hopes" on "paper" so to speak :)

"To discuss evil in a manner implying neutrality, is to sanction it." AR

………… parent

BTW

the post on RS looks better because our software removes all the white space. Anyway you can fix that?

I came. I saw. I posted.
Veni, Vidi, Bitchy.

………… parent

Romney ran a good race

but he won't make it. I think he would be a fine President, but he is running 10 points behind each of the two possible Dem candidates in the polls, whereas McCain is running even. So as a former Rudy supporter I will be voting for McCain in the primary.

name the enemy, win the war

…………

it doesn't matter how Romney runs against dems

right now. It's impossible to speculate before the actual General campaign. Therefor you should vote for Romney. I firmly believe McCain would get slaughtered once he shows off his doddering nastiness.

"To discuss evil in a manner implying neutrality, is to sanction it." AR

………… parent

I wish Romney luck.

The more I see McCain surge toward the nomination on a wave of militarism, Big brother conservatism and dirty, nasty campaigning, the more I want him to lose the nomination.

It's like MacArthur running for president.

…………

Good info!

Of course it doesn't matter which of these Republican lock losers gets the nomination with George W. Bush hanging around their neck like a 500 pound anvil ;-)

Romney won't crack 20% in West Virginia. McCain will romp there, and Huckabee probably will finish 2nd. Sorry man :-( Personally I'd love Romney to win the nomination because I think he has no chance to win the election.

BTW, I think you have the Massachusetts numbers reversed..

…………

hehe thanks on the MA numbers

no one on RS mentioned it. I'll do a final update Monday night.

I think Romney has a chance in West Virginia... We'll see :)

"To discuss evil in a manner implying neutrality, is to sanction it." AR

………… parent